Despite their desire to be led rather than to lead, research by PsychTests reveals that employees who are followers are less amenable to coaching.
Montreal, Canada – May 01, 2014 – There is a lot of talk on the web about leadership. Googling “leadership development” yields more than half a billion results with articles such as “The # 1 reason leaders fail,” “Top 5 skills of successful leaders,” and “10 biggest challenges of today’s leaders.” But what about followers? Google “follower development “and you will find very little, and the information out there on the latter topic is focused on how leadership impacts followers. It may almost seem old-fashioned to be a follower in a culture of deified leaders, but the truth is, it takes many more followers than leaders for an organization to perform. Companies need employees who will get work done as expected and carry out assignments or orders to the best of their ability. Research from PsychTests reveals a surprising twist regarding seemingly compliant employees, however.
In their analyses of data collected for their Coachability Test, researchers at PsychTests compared people who prefer to lead (Leaders), to those who prefer to follow (Followers), and those who are comfortable both leading and following, depending on the situation (Adapters). In general, the overall coachability scores were fairly high, indicating that most people are quite open to coaching. However, among the three identified groups, it was the Followers who were the least willing to be coached while the Adapters were the most open.
Here are some of the most notable results of the PsychTests study (scores are reported on a scale from 0 to 100):
- Followers are the most willing to take direction (score of 75 – close to Adapters with average score of 74, compared to only 65 for Leaders).
- Followers are the least comfortable admitting their faults and weakness (score of 61, compared to 66 for Leaders and 71 for Adapters).
- Followers are the least capable of handling criticism (score of 68, compared to 71 for Leaders and 76 for Adapters).
- Followers are the least willing to ask for help, even when they need it (score of 65, compared to 69 for Leaders and 74 for Adapters).
- Followers are the least open to learning and improvement (score of 78, compared to an average score of 82 for Leaders and 85 for Adapters).
- Adapters scored the lowest on “Know-it-all-ism” (score of 24, vs. 27 for Followers and 33 for Leaders).
The question is, why would followers find it harder to accept coaching, given that it is to their benefit?
“The answer lies in their perspective – what coaching means to them,” explains Dr. Jerabek, president of PsychTests. “Followers seem to have a bit of a self-confidence issue. Being criticized makes them feel weak, incompetent, or incapable; they feel a little insecure about their job and they simply get scared when they have to admit a mistake or a weakness. When you offer coaching or training to Followers, they may take it as an indication that something is wrong and that’s why they need help. The Adapters, on the other hand, see coaching as an opportunity. They recognize that in the long-run, it helps them to become better employees and better people.”
So while most followers want to learn, grow, and improve, PsychTests’ statistics indicate that they have yet to reach the level of openness and willingness that the Adapters show. For example:
- 82% of the Adapters actively seek out learning opportunities, compared to 56% of Followers.
- 88% of the Adapters have upgraded their skills or taken educational courses in the last two years, compared to 77% of Followers.
- 91% of the Adapters recognize that even negative criticism can be helpful, compared to 77% of Followers.
- 57% of the Adapters actively seek out feedback from their manager, compared to 37% of Followers.
- 84% of the Adapters actively participate in their performance evaluations (taking notes, asking questions, etc.), compared to 65% of Followers.
- 83% of the Adapters report that when they listened to feedback in the past, it helped them become a better person, compared to 65% of Followers.
“Given that most followers are in fact fairly open to learning and improvement, I think it boils down to one major point: Insecurity,” explains Dr. Jerabek. “They know that their manager’s desire to coach them is actually a good thing, but they still see it as ‘I’m not good enough.’ This can result in discomfort or even resentment in response to coaching attempts. Help them overcome the insecurity, help them recognize that you’re doing it because you see their potential, and you’ll get a totally different attitude – not only to coaching but also to their job in general. So if you want to develop your followers, make sure they understand that your company wants to invest in them because they are worth it, that it is an opportunity rather than punishment.”
“It is clear, however, that hiring Adapters – employees who are able to be a leader and a follower – is an advantage,” concludes Dr. Jerabek. “They have the best of both worlds, and most importantly, are open to learning, to improvement, to direction, and to feedback. When the time is right, they also make the best leaders. Companies need this type of versatility.”
Want to assess your level of coachability? Go to http://testyourself.psychtests.com/testid/3478
Professional users of this assessment (HR professionals, therapists, coaches and consultants) can request a free demo of this or any other tests from ARCH Profile’s extensive battery: http://hrtests.archprofile.com/testdrive_gen_1
About PsychTests AIM Inc.:
PsychTests AIM Inc. originally appeared on the internet scene in 1996. Since its inception, it has become a pre-eminent provider of psychological assessment products and services to human resource personnel, therapists, academics, researchers and a host of other professionals around the world. PsychTests AIM Inc. staff is comprised of a dedicated team of psychologists, test developers, researchers, statisticians, writers, and artificial intelligence experts (see ARCHProfile.com). The company’s research division, Plumeus Inc., is supported in part by Research and Development Tax Credit awarded by Industry Canada.
President of PsychTests AIM Inc.
9001 Boul. De L’Acadie, Suite 802
Montreal, Quebec, H4N 3H5
tel: 514-745-3189, ext. 112